Should you talk about your weaknesses in interview?
I know I am going against popular opinion when I say this, but my view is yes.
So if you are looking here for an easy answer on how to answer the weakness question in interview, then look somewhere else. There are plenty of other sites where you can find a prescribed script.
Most intelligent interviewers want to get a sense of the real you.
OK, they know that you are not going to reveal your worst character flaw. But they do want to get a sense that they are talking to a real person, not an automation who cannot talk about anything other than their strengths. Nor do they really want to employ someone who dodges the question with a cliché answer.
All of the employers we interviewed for our book “What do employers really want” lamented the lack of self awareness among their teams and among people they interviewed.
They simply wanted people to be themselves in interview.
Here’s what one employer said: (She’s a senior executive in the world’s biggest supplier of information.)
-A turn off in interview is when people are constantly in “sell mode”. Sometimes it’s nervousness, so I allow time for an applicant to get through that. Then there are people who use “sell” as a barrier. They are the more difficult ones to deal with, because they will not let the barrier down. I’m not really getting to know them, so why would I want to employ them. I would rather someone say. “Look I have no experience in that area, but I think my skills would work really well, here.”
Another employer, a senior HR Manager, said:
“What turns me off is desperation from a candidate, where people try to oversell themselves, who have given you a 50 page CV and over-emphasized their qualifications. There’s a level of over-kill that some people tend to go past”
Think about it this way.
You are in an interview because the strengths you have, lend themselves to that profession. A weakness you may have, may not actually be a deal breaker. We all know accountants or engineers who are not people people. They are not being hired for that, they are being hired for their technical skills.
The bottom line on talking weaknesses is to be genuine.
Have a real conversation.
If you can show that you understand what you are good at, what you are not good at, then talk about what you are doing about it, then you are coming closer to a real conversation about whether the role is right for you, and whether you are right for the role.
That’s kind of the point of an interview, isn’t it?
PS: Please don’t ask me if you should say that your weakness is that you care too much about the job. I get kind of cranky! 😉
Need to get ahead of the pack for your next interview?
Get our free e-book The 7 Deadly Sins to Avoid at Job Interview!
Deborah Barit wrote this book. She is one of Australia’s leading interview coaches.
To get your free e-book and some of our best interview tips direct to your inbox, simply click on this link.
Here’s what happy readers said about the e-book and interview tips:
“Deborah Barit is a very smart lady…She is good at figuring out what an employer is looking for. It’s like she has ESP, with her help in preparing, I found no surprises in a recent interview and I was prepared for every question….” Cathy, Leichhardt, NSW
“Because I read so many of your posts, I feel as if you were my personal employment coach. I start my new position in two weeks. I had so many obstacles to overcome and each day you posted a solution to my dilemma and how to improve my search. Thank you so much for your input and PLEASE continue to do what you do!”
{ 14 comments… read them below or add one }
If I say my weakness is in the area of presentations (nervous about speaking in front of people), there are some big assumptions that come from that. The interviewer might assume that: I’m not confident in my abilities; I’m generally a nervous, anxious person; I’m somehow weak and passive in dealing with people. Will an interviewer believe me if I say that I don’t have those issues?
I think you could try to give your comment some context. For example, you could say you don’t get nervous one-on-one, but you do get nervous when delivering a large presentation. Also the interveiwer judges you in the way that you appear, not just by what you say. So if you appear nervous as you say it, then they may make more of the big assumptions that you talk about. So try to give your answer some specifics and then perhaps talk about how you work on this. For example by practicing your presentation in front of a mirror/friends etc.
I was told by one who interviewed a lot, that if a candidate said “I don’t have any weaknesses”, that she interpreted this as “This person can’t tell the truth, for we all have weaknesses.” Better she said to admit to a liking for chocolate, or to penchant for tidiness. Something pretty banal – not a major flaw that could trash ones chances.
RT @InterviewIQ: #interviews How to handle the “do you have any weaknesses†question in interviews http://interviewiq.com.au/do-you-have-an…
#interviews How to handle the “do you have any weaknesses†question in interviews http://interviewiq.com.au/do-you-have-an…
RT @InterviewIQ: #interviews How to handle the “do you have any weaknesses†question in interviews http://interviewiq.com.au/do-you-have-an…
#interviews How to handle the “do you have any weaknesses†question in interviews http://interviewiq.com.au/do-you-have-an…
RT @InterviewIQ: #interviews How to handle the “do you have any weaknesses†question in interviews http://interviewiq.com.au/do-you-have-an…
#interviews How to handle the “do you have any weaknesses†question in interviews http://interviewiq.com.au/do-you-have-an…
I’ve always interpreted this question as an attempt to gauge a candidate’s self-awareness, so I heartily approve of the answer here!
Thanks Ed. Much appreciated.
A great post from Karalyn @InterviewIQ
Thanks KB!
“@InterviewIQ: Do you have any weaknesses? http://t.co/qdXjOSKB #jobinterviewâ€
Ok, agreed on being genuine and real, but I need to know if the Weakness should have any relation to the position, company character? Or it could be a general weakness which, as you said, may has nothing to do with job requirement.
For example I’m in an interview for a position like Executive Assistant to a CEO and I hate my desk, room & surroundings being crowded. It won’t work for sure. You will be in contact with too many, depending on the company volume.
May be it would have been ideal if the interviewer set up an example or a scenario which concentrates on a couple of key behaviors and ask the candidates to act. The result wouldn’t be dependently trustable but at least will give a clue.
I know that you will say, the interviewer will also see how you present yourself and the rest of the story.
And at the end I agree with you dear Karalyn and I’m thanking you for sharing all these useful experiences.
p.s. But what if a talented professional miss a chance only because of his / her lack of awareness or not having a proper presentation skills. Do the interviewers are equipped with a kind of strategy to distinguish them from the others? Does it really matters to the employers not to lose a right employee?
 Do you have any weaknesses? http://t.co/KPLCFr10 #jobsearch http://t.co/iMNk3Ded
{ 3 trackbacks }